Is music able to express the tragic?

  • Enrico Fubini Università degli Studi di Torino, Italia
  • Francesco Consiglio Universidad de Granada, España
Keywords: Tragic, Harmony, Monodic Music, Instrumental Music, Melodrama

Abstract

This writing raises the question if the musical art is able to really express the  feeling of the tragic, and tries to clarify the relation that exist (if it exists) between the concept of the tragic and the language of music. In particular, it aims to reconstruct the history of this relation beginning by its roots, sunk in Greek tragedy, to arrive at its nearer expressions in the XX century. The accent is on the tragic value of the musical content itself, emphasizing in particular, in the case of the melodrama, the relation that arise between an emotion expressed in words and that that is born of music itself, as well as the apparent contradiction between the beauty of the harmony of polyphonic music and the feeling of the truly tragic.

Author Biographies

Enrico Fubini, Università degli Studi di Torino, Italia

Enrico Fubini (PhD) is Professore Emerito in History of Music at the Università di Torino, Italy. 

Francesco Consiglio, Universidad de Granada, España

Francesco Consiglio is a member of the research project “On the origin and epistemology of categories: Identity, Causality, Object: PID2019-108870GB-I00 (AEI)”; he also was member of the research project “Habla interna, metacognición y la concepción narrativa de la identidad” (MINECO: FFI2015–65953–P). He is member of the International Research Network "Studia Humanitatis"; he is also member of the FiloLab Excellence Unit at the University of Granada, Spain. He is PhD in Philosophy of Mind at the University of Granada. He studied at the universities of Siena (Laurea Triennale in Filosofia), Parma (Laurea  Magistrale  in  Filosofia)  and  Salamanca.  He mainly focused, during his studies, on Theory of Knowledge and Philosophy of Mind.  More recently, he focused on Theory of Collective Intelligence and social cognition with a particular focus on aesthetics, manipulation of artefacts and public representations. He published both articles and translations in various Spanish and Italian journals of philosophy and he gave talks in various congresses around Europe.

Published
2013-12-20
How to Cite
[1]
Fubini, E. and Consiglio, F. 2013. Is music able to express the tragic?. Disputatio. 2, 3 (Dec. 2013), 5-22.
Section
Articles and Essays