REVIEW OF GAME-BASED LEARNING IN SECONDARY EDUCATION: CONSIDERING THE TYPES OF VIDEO GAMES
Nuevas tecnologías en el proceso de enseñanza-aprendizaje
Loja: Universidad Técnica Particular de Loja, 2019, pp. 1-10
ISBN: 978-9942-25-433-7 | Analysis vol. 22 | pdf/doi: 10.5281/zenodo.0000000
Abstract:Video games are increasingly used as educational resources in today’s classrooms. In that sense, this paper shows a systematic review of game–based learning in Secondary Education to know the results of its implementation in this educational level. In total, 951 articles were found in repositories and 23 papers were included applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria. From a pedagogical point of view, most video games used in the studies are designed for learning, not for entertainment. The most used and most effective type of games are ‘animated tutorial’, ‘simulation’, ‘puzzle’, ‘role–playing’ and ‘strategy’.
Key Words: Databases; Search Terms; Serious games; 12-16-year-old students.
Video games are digital leisure resources commonly used by young people and are one of the most popular forms of entertainment today. Furthermore, video games are increasingly used as educational resources in today’s classrooms (Martín, Basilotta and García–Valcárcel 2017). Video games can be a powerful educational tool, in particular, for secondary education, but we need to know the real results of the implementation of video games in this stage to disseminate this practice to all the schools
In this paper, it is proposed to carry out a systematic review of the literature that enables to know the objective results of the application of video games in secondary education (based on research results), considering the age range from 12 to 16 years.
In this study, we applied a systematic literature review method to locate, critically evaluate, and synthesize studies about effects of video games focused on their impact on learning outcomes in 12–16–year–old students. Petticrew and Roberts (2008) defined a systematic literature review as an interpretation of a selection of documents on a specific topic that involves summarization, analysis, evaluation, and synthesis of the documents.
Taking into account that this paper is part of a broader systematic literature review, the general aim of the systematic literature review is to look for evidence about the effects of video games related to their impact on learning outcomes in 12–16–year–old students. Considering that, in this paper we focus on three research question of the systematic review:
- What are the main objectives of the video games used in the studies (taking into account Games for learning–Serious Games or Entertainment Games–Commercial Off–The–Shelf Games)?
- What genre of video games has been used more often in schools (Action, Adventure, Animated tutorial, Puzzle, Role–playing, Simulation, Sports, Strategy, Platform, Virtual reality, Virtual Word, Augmented Reality, Other Types, Not specified)? To stablish the classification of genres we adapted the proposal used by Hainey et al. (2016) in their systematic literature review.
- What kind of video game is more effective from a pedagogical point of view?
To carry out the systematic review we used the following databases: Science Direct and Scopus. Also, the search terms employed were: games AND “secondary education” AND learning. Furthermore, a series of inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied to select the appropriate studies to include in the review (as can be seen in Appendix 1).
As results, 951 articles were found in repositories and 23 papers were included applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria (see Apprendix 2).
In terms of the specific questions, the results of the 3 research questions are shown in the following sections.
Research question 1: What are the main objectives of the video games used in the studies? The video games used in the analysed studies were mostly video games originally designed for learning purposes (which could be included within the label Serious Games), namely, 19 studies. Only 4 studies presented the use of entertainment video games (COTS or Commercial Off–The–Shelf Games) (see Appendix 3).
Research question 2: What genre of video games has been used more often in schools? Firstly, it should be noted that, in this case, the studies analysed can be categorized in different genres of video games since they can refer to several video games or because the same video game can present characteristics or belong to several genres of video games. That said, the genres or types of video games mostly used in the selected studies were ‘Animated tutorial’ and ‘Simulation’ accounting for eight studies that incorporate these types of video games, followed by ‘Puzzle’ with seven studies, and ‘Role–Playing’ and ‘Strategy’ with six (see Appendix 4)
Research question 3: What kind of video game is more effective from a pedagogical point of view? Given the use of different types in the studies included in this systematic review, we can consider that the genres of video games that are most effective from a pedagogical point of view are the Animated tutorial (used in 8 studies), Simulation (used in 8 studies), Puzzle (used in 7 studies), Strategy (used in 6 studies) and Role–Playing (used in 6 studies). We can consider that the animated tutorials present situations in which different issues are taught as a tutorial with animations of the characters or situations. On the other hand, simulation allows us to create and generate situations in virtual worlds that simulate reality allowing us to experiment and test without suffering damage in a safe environment. Puzzle and strategy can favour reasoning, the search for strategies and plans to solve the problems that arise. Finally, Role–Playing games allow the students to assume the role of a character and to experience different identities as well as the consequences of actions in a virtual world.
Conclusiones And Scientific Of The Study
The results of the present study, which is part of a broader systematic review of the literature on the educational effects of video games in secondary education, help to highlight the educational potential of video games.
From a pedagogical point of view, most video games used in the studies are designed for learning, not for entertainment. The most used and most effective type of games are ‘animated tutorial’, ‘simulation’, ‘puzzle’, ‘role–playing’ and ‘strategy’.
We are aware that our research may have three limitations. The first is the number of databases used. We only used Science Direct and Scopus because we could access to the articles from those databases thanks to our University. The second is the number of research terms. We only used games AND “secondary education” AND learning. The third limitation can be the classification of video games by genre. There are different classifications of video games in terms of genre and, also, a video game can be categorized in different genres by different authors due to their characteristics.
Despite these limitations, we believe our work could be the basis for a more detailed and deeper systematic review on the educational use and the educational effects of video games in 12–16–year–old students, taking into account that this paper was focused solely on the main objectives of the video games used, the genre of video games and the kind of video games that is more effective from a pedagogical point of view. Further work needs to be done in other databases and with more detailed research terms. Also, our future work will concentrate on the effectiveness of different video game genres in learning in other stages (e.g. Primary Education, Higher Education, and Vocational Training).
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No732420.
This publication reflects only the author’s view. It does not represent the view of the European Commission and the European Commission is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains.
Hainey, Thomas; Connolly, Thomas M.; Boyle, Elizabeth A; Wilson, Amanda & Razak, Aisya (2016). «A systematic literature review of games–based learning empirical evidence in primary education». Computers & Education 102: pp. 202–223. Doi: 10.1016/j.compedu.2016.09.001
Martín, Marta; Basilotta, Verónica & García–Valcárcel, Ana (2017). «A quantitative approach to pre–service primary school teachers’ attitudes towards collaborative learning with video games: previous experience with video games can make the difference». International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education 14, no. 11: pp. 1–18. doi:10.1186/s41239-017-0050-5
Petticrew, Mark & Roberts, Helen (2008). Systematic reviews in the social sciences: A practical guide. Malden, MA: Wiley.